top of page

What a Four-Number Puzzle Can Teach About Mathematical Creativity

5 days ago
5 min read

Updated: 5 days ago

Guest article by Elvinik, Math24Solver.com


“Math 24 Game Solver.” 2026. 24 Game Solver - Every Solution for Any 4 Numbers, Free. Accessed November 14. https://math24solver.com/math-24-game-solver.
“Math 24 Game Solver.” 2026. 24 Game Solver - Every Solution for Any 4 Numbers, Free. Accessed November 14. https://math24solver.com/math-24-game-solver.

The 24 game hands the player four numbers and asks for a single result of exactly 24, using addition, subtraction, multiplication and division, with each number used once. Most players stop as soon as they reach 24, and the format encourages it, since a timer rewards the first valid answer. Yet many number sets allow several legal routes, and comparing those routes shows how differently the same four numbers can be organised. That comparison is the part of the game I find most interesting.

Take 2, 4, 6 and 8, the set I proposed when I offered this piece to the blog. One route is 8 x 6 / (4 - 2): the 4 and the 2 collapse into a divisor of 2, and 48 divided by 2 gives 24. Another is 8 x 4 - 6 - 2, which builds 32 and then removes 8 in two steps. The first route is built on a quotient, the second on a surplus that is trimmed back. Both are correct, and a player who finds only one of them has seen only half of what the numbers permit.

I develop practical math-practice tools, and one of them is a free Make-24 site at https://math24solver.com/. It offers the classic game with timed or untimed play, a version for children whose modes exclude division or use only addition and subtraction, a 10-puzzle challenge, a solver that lists valid solutions for any four numbers, a page of rules and strategies, and printable puzzle sheets for home, tutoring and classroom use. I run it as an independent educational project, and it is not affiliated with Suntex International Inc. My aim was to keep the rules clear and the feedback immediate. I make no larger claim for it, because a puzzle of this size cannot teach mathematics as a whole.

What it does show, with unusual economy, is something that school arithmetic often hides. Textbook problems usually carry one expected answer reached by one expected method, so learners come to treat the method as part of the question. The mathematician Paul Lockhart made this complaint at length in his essay “A Mathematician’s Lament,” arguing that the creative activity of mathematics is largely absent from the classroom. George Pólya, in “How to Solve It” (1945), asked problem solvers to look back after finding a result and ask whether it could be derived differently. Few learners are ever asked to do that, because a correct answer ends the exercise. A game in which a second route is the goal restores that step.

A related and better documented problem is fixation on a familiar method. In experiments reported by Abraham Luchins in 1942, participants who had practised a long procedure on a series of water-jar problems kept applying it to later problems that a much shorter procedure would have solved. This is usually called the Einstellung effect. The 24 game produces a milder form of it constantly: players who have found that factor pairs such as 3 x 8 or 4 x 6 often work will reach for them first, and will miss the sets where they do not.

Some of the most instructive sets are the ones where the player is held back by a rule nobody imposed. My site lists 3, 3, 8 and 8 as an example. The solution is 8 / (3 - 8 / 3), which passes through the intermediate value of one third before reaching 24. Players who believe every step must produce a whole number will conclude that the set is impossible, although the rules explicitly allow fractions. The set 1, 3, 4 and 6 works the same way: 6 / (1 - 3 / 4) turns the three quarters into a single quarter and divides 6 by it. In both cases the obstacle is an assumption the player brought along, and the puzzle gives immediate and unambiguous evidence that the assumption was wrong.

A solver changes this picture in two opposite ways, and I think it fair to say so, since I built one. A player who consults it before thinking has removed the search that makes the puzzle useful. A player who first finds one route and then uses the solver to see what else exists receives a map of alternatives to compare with the one they found. The site also acknowledges that some sets cannot reach 24 at all, which teaches something often missing from classroom practice: a problem may have no solution, and checking systematically is itself a respectable result.

It would be an overstatement to call this creativity in the sense of professional mathematical invention, which Henri Poincaré and Jacques Hadamard described in their accounts of incubation and sudden insight and which no four-number puzzle reproduces. It is also contested how far a skill practised on one kind of puzzle transfers to others, and a puzzle site cannot settle that. What the activity does exercise is cognitive flexibility on a very small scale: abandoning the first workable approach, tolerating a detour through fractions, and judging two correct answers against each other. Because the numbers are dealt at random, the player has no prepared strategy for the particular set.

That is the same reason Grandomastery (https://www.grandomastery.com) builds its tasks from randomized prompts and asks for responses that are interesting and not merely correct, and it is why I thought this practice belonged on its blog.

The warmup I describe for this blog follows from that reasoning. It starts from a randomly presented set, asks for a second legal path, and spends about five minutes comparing the paths found. I regard small tools of this kind as worth attention for that reason: a few minutes of play can establish the habit of asking whether another route exists before accepting the first one.


This material has been submitted to Grandomastery and is currently featured in the ESL Treasures Awards (https://grandomastery.com/esltreasures), a free recognition programme for excellent but under-the-radar resources. ESL Treasures is open not only to creators of ESL and ELT materials but to everyone who develops EdTech resources that can be useful to learners of English as a second or foreign language, whether or not the tool was built with English teaching in mind. Submissions are accepted on an ongoing basis, and reviewed work can receive an award certificate and a place in the Grandomastery blog (https://grandomastery.com/submit), the Grandomastery LinkedIn community (https://www.linkedin.com/in/grandomastery/) and a free WhatsApp peer-review group (https://bit.ly/Grandomastery). Further opportunities for resource creators and educators include a free tutor portfolio listing (https://grandomastery.com/tutors), custom ESL scripts, games and randomizers built free of charge in exchange for feedback or posts (https://wa.link/grandomastery), and a Teachers Pay Teachers store for publishing demos (https://teacherspayteachers.com/store/grandomastery). To send your own resource for review, visit https://grandomastery.com/esltreasures.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page